Why Optimism and Pessimism Are the Same…If You Don’t Act

Written by: Can Dillioglu

Published: July 6, 2025

The Honest Trap No One Talks About

Everyone loves talking about mindset.

Be more optimistic. Visualize success. Stay positive.

Or the opposite. Be realistic. Expect failure. Protect yourself through pessimism.

But here’s the truth I’ve lived:

Optimism and pessimism are exactly the same if you don’t act.

You can believe life is going to be incredible. You can believe life is going to suck.

Both mean nothing if you sit still.

Mindset without movement is just noise in your head.

Also, see here: The Truth About Mindsets, And How They Quietly Shape Your Life

Mindset content is everywhere. But here’s what most people miss:

You can feel good and get nowhere. You can feel bad and still move forward.

The trap is thinking you need to feel right before doing something that matters.

That trap wastes months. Years. Sometimes decades.

And the worst part? You often don’t notice it’s happening until it’s too late.

When I Realized Both Sides Are Traps

I used to be wildly optimistic about my future.

I believed I’d build something meaningful. That things would work out.

But I didn’t move. I didn’t take the next step. Nothing happened.

Then came disappointment. I flipped scripts:

“Maybe I’ll never make it. Maybe there are too many people already doing what I want to do.”

That pessimism felt more honest. But it was the same trap.

I wasn’t acting. I was overthinking.

Different belief. Same result.

That’s when it clicked for me:

It’s not about what you believe. It’s about what you do.

We spend so much time obsessing over how we feel. Whether we are in the right headspace, whether our mindset is strong enough, whether we believe in ourselves yet. But life does not pause while you figure that out. What really matters is what you put into motion.

As long as you keep asking yourself, “Do I believe in this?” you delay the only thing that creates belief in the first place: experience. Confidence is not built in theory. It is built when reality pushes back and you realize you can handle it.

That is why both optimism and pessimism can become traps. Optimism can make you passive, assuming good things will just happen. Pessimism can make you hesitant, assuming it is not even worth trying. But neither mindset is inherently right or wrong. They are just lenses.

What matters is what you do through the lens. A clear-eyed pessimist who moves beats a delusional optimist who waits. Every time.

Why Life Doesn’t Care About Your Mindset

Life isn’t good or bad. It just is.

We layer it with our own stories:

“The world is full of opportunity.”

“The world is rigged against me.”

Both can feel true depending on how you look at things. But neither matters until you step into the arena yourself.

Real confidence isn’t built from belief.

It’s built from movement.

The Stoics knew this. Marcus Aurelius wrote:

“The impediment to action advances action. What stands in the way becomes the way.”

Zen Buddhism echoes it:

“Before enlightenment, chop wood, carry water. After enlightenment, chop wood, carry water.”

And psychology backs it. Albert Ellis, founder of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy, taught:

“It’s not what you feel that matters. It’s what you do despite those feelings.”

Modern CBT is based on this: You don’t wait until you feel ready. You move first.

The Mindset-Action Feedback Loop That Actually Works

Forget optimism versus pessimism.

Here’s what actually creates progress:

  1. See where you’re at: optimistic, pessimistic, whatever.
  2. Move anyway.
  3. Watch what happens.
  4. Adjust.
  5. Repeat.

Most people get stuck before step two.

They think they need belief first.

But belief follows action, not the other way around.

How I Broke the Cycle (Without a Grand Epiphany)

There was no lightning-bolt moment for me.

One day I just got tired of my own excuses.

I asked myself:

“What’s one small thing I can do today that moves me forward whether or not I believe in it right now?”

That was it.

Not a perfect plan. Not total clarity. Just movement.

I realized I didn’t need optimism to move. I could feel pessimistic and still execute.

Action became my baseline. Mindset became optional.

How You Can Apply This Starting Today

Pessimism won’t save you. Optimism won’t save you. Only action will.

That’s not a motivational quote. It’s real life.

You can have days where everything feels dark and still move forward.

You can have days where everything feels bright and waste them.

The person who moves no matter what wins long-term.

And every day you move despite your mood, you teach yourself you’re not controlled by mindset.

You create mindset through action.

Why I Wrote This

This is personal for me.

I spent years floating between optimism and pessimism, feeling smart about both.

What I really was? Stuck.

I write this because I know some of you feel the same.

If even one of you reads this and decides to take a step today, despite doubt, that’s why this exists.

Now, What?

Forget optimism. Forget pessimism. For now.

Grab a pen.

Write down the thing you’ve been hesitating on:

That project. That conversation. That habit.

Now ask yourself:

“What’s the next small move I can take today whether I believe in it or not?”

Take it.

Then tomorrow, take another.

Your Challenge

Right now:

  • Write down one thing you’ve been putting off.
  • Identify one small step you can take today.
  • Commit to moving whether or not you feel like it.

That’s it.

Mindset is overrated. Movement is everything.

About Me

Can Dillioglu

My strong fields of interest are holistic nutrition, entrepreneurship and personal development with a passion for empowering individuals to achieve their best health, business success, and personal growth.I help people cut through information overload to make clear, independent decisions that prioritize long-term well-being. My work focuses on honesty, authenticity, and building relationships.

Inner Circle

Related

1 Comment

  1. Leon

    Very Insightful and to the point! Theodore Roosevelt said “Comparison is the thief of Joy”.
    Rationally it only makes sense to compare yourself to… yourself from the day/month/year before. As you said we all have different backgrounds (genes, upbringing, resources and karma to deal with).
    Growth mindset = learning mindset. I believe we are all here (on earth) to learn. This mindset allows to celebrate both successes and failures as amazing growth opportunities..

    Can’t wait for more articles from you!

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join the Inner Circle

No spam. No empty promises. Just meaningful signals in the noise.